Speaker Julie Menin announced October 13 that SpaceXAI will testify before the City Council’s Committee on Technology on October 16, ending a subpoena standoff the Council was prepared to escalate to the New York State Supreme Court. Elon Musk’s company folded within days of the Council signaling it would seek judicial enforcement and penalties under New York City law.

The sequencing matters. Menin and General Counsel Nwamaka Ejebe sent voluntary letters to five AI companies between September 15 and 17; four committed by September 27; the subpoena issued September 28. SpaceXAI skipped the October 5 Committee of the Whole, a nearly 10-hour session in which 46 council members questioned Anthropic, OpenAI, Google, and Meta under oath. On October 7, SpaceXAI requested a meeting and agreed to appear.

The probe’s framing is explicit. The Council’s original letter sought to “assess whether fast-emerging risks to public safety, cybersecurity, economic stability, privacy, consumers and businesses warrant immediate legislative action to protect New Yorkers.” That language is doing structural work: it’s the predicate for a package of AI legislation covering any business that sells or deploys AI in the city, including mandatory third-party validation and a 24-hour incident-reporting requirement for city agencies and contractors.

At the October 5 hearing, OpenAI’s Morgan Dwyer, Anthropic’s Logan Graham, Meta’s Shane Cahill, and Google’s Alice Friend declined to put a number on catastrophic-risk probability or commit that failing an independent safety test would block a release. “I think a simple yes or no would instill more confidence in the public on a matter as serious as this,” Menin said. Anthropic whistleblower Jacob Coxon told members it was “more likely than not” that humanity could eventually lose control of advanced AI systems.

The target is a $2 trillion-plus conglomerate, Musk folded xAI into SpaceX in February, took SpaceX public in June, and completed a $60 billion acquisition of Cursor in August, with Grok now serving federal agencies including the Pentagon. “When the federal government fails to act, cities take the lead and that’s exactly what the New York City Council has done today,” Menin said. Friday’s hearing is the evidentiary record for the bills already drafted.

Sources

Sources